Top 5 Mistakes New Bullion Investors Make (and How to Avoid Them)

Top 5 Mistakes New Bullion Investors Make (and How to Avoid Them)

Investing in physical gold and silver is a smart move for anyone looking to diversify their portfolio and protect against inflation. But like any investment, bullion comes with its own set of pitfalls — especially for newcomers. If you're just getting started, being aware of common mistakes can save you a lot of money and frustration. Here are the top five mistakes new bullion investors make, and how to avoid them.

1. Paying Too Much Over Spot Price

Many beginners don't realize how much premiums (the cost above the metal's spot price) can vary. It's easy to get excited and overpay, especially when buying small quantities or fancy designs. While collectible coins can justify higher premiums, basic bullion purchases should focus on minimizing that premium.

How to Avoid It:

  • Compare prices across multiple reputable dealers.

  • Stick to well-known bullion products with low premiums, like generic silver rounds, American Silver Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, or gold bars from trusted private and government refiners.

  • Understand what "spot price" means and always check it before buying.

2. Prioritizing "Pretty" Coins Over Bullion Value

New investors sometimes confuse bullion investing with numismatic (collectible) coin collecting. There's nothing wrong with buying coins for beauty or collectibility, but it should be intentional, not accidental. Rare and graded coins carry hefty premiums that may not track the value of gold or silver itself.

How to Avoid It:

  • Know whether you're buying bullion for its metal value or coins for collectibility.

  • For pure investment purposes, focus on common-date, non-numismatic bullion products. Many government minted gold and silver coins (e.g., American Gold/Silver Eagles, Canadian Gold/Silver Maple Leaf, etc.) are intentionally struck by the producing government with non-collectibility in mind (i.e., the coins are struck solely for bullion investment purposes). 

3. Ignoring Storage and Security

Once you have a small stack of gold and silver, storage becomes a serious concern. Too many beginners just stash metals in a desk drawer or "hide" them at home without thinking about theft, fire, or accessibility.

How to Avoid It:

  • Invest in a quality safe that's bolted down.

  • Consider professional vault storage if your holdings grow large.

  • Above all, keep your holdings discreet; avoid telling many people what you own.

4. Failing to Understand Liquidity

Gold and silver are valuable, but they’re not quite "cash." Not all bullion products sell quickly or easily. Highly unusual items, obscure brands, or high-premium collectibles might be harder to resell when you need cash fast.

How to Avoid It:

  • Stick with widely recognized bullion products.

  • Think ahead about how easy (or hard) it will be to liquidate your metals.

5. Timing the Market Too Aggressively

Many new investors try to "buy the dip" or "wait for the bottom" — and end up doing nothing. Others panic and buy heavily at peak prices. Timing precious metals markets is extremely difficult, even for professionals.

How to Avoid It:

  • Consider regular purchases (dollar cost averaging or DCA'ing) to smooth out price swings.

  • Remember that bullion investing is usually a long-term strategy, not a short-term trade.

  • Focus on your personal financial goals, not market noise.

Final Thoughts

Gold and silver can be a powerful part of a diversified investment strategy. By avoiding these common mistakes, you'll be setting yourself up for success from the start. Stay informed and stay patient.

Back to blog